top of page

Making $500K and Still Living Paycheck to Paycheck?

Writer: Will Allen
Will Allen
Oct 8
18 min read

Updated: Oct 9

You would think making $500,000 a year would make it easier to get ahead financially. But a new Goldman Sachs survey found that 37% of people earning more than $500,000 say they’re living paycheck to paycheck. In this video, we look at how that happens and why having a personalized financial plan matters, no matter how much you make. In the same survey, 72% of people with a personalized plan said they feel on track for retirement, compared with just 33% of those without one. Meanwhile, stocks are hitting all-time highs even as interest rates keep climbing. That’s a combination you don’t normally see. We look at how well tech has held up, the big sell-offs investors have had to endure along the way, and what the latest jobs numbers tell us. We also look at how the stock market has performed in the fourth quarter during midterm election years compared with all other years.


Video Recap

Prefer to read instead of watch? Here's the full breakdown


Paycheck to Paycheck by Income

In this week’s video, we led off with Goldman Sachs Asset Management’s 2026 Retirement Survey, which looked at how many Americans are living paycheck to paycheck at each income level. As you would expect, the share falls as income goes up at first, from 61% of workers earning under $50,000 to 22% of those earning $100,000 to $200,000. Above $200,000, the share rises in every bracket.


The number that surprised us most came from the top of the income scale. Among people earning more than $500,000 a year, 37% said they live paycheck to paycheck, a higher percentage than people earning $50,000 to $100,000. You can see the full breakdown in the chart below.


Bar chart of the share of working respondents living paycheck to paycheck by annual income in Goldman Sachs Asset Management's 2026 Retirement Survey, falling from 61% under $50,000 to 22% at $100,000 to $200,000 and rising back to 37% above $500,000.

We see this in our own conversations. We have sat across from households earning $400,000 to $600,000 a year who carry more on their credit cards than they hold in savings. Most of the time the cause is lifestyle creep. A bigger income makes a bigger house and private school tuition feel affordable, and watching neighbors and coworkers do the same makes it feel normal.


The habit that protects against it is easy to describe and harder to keep. When a raise comes, save a meaningful part of it before the new spending level settles in. Money that never reaches the checking account is much harder to spend, and this habit matters most early in a career, when each raise sets the baseline for the next one.


Planning and Retirement Confidence


The same survey found a wide gap in retirement confidence depending on whether someone has a plan. 72% of respondents with a personalized plan said their retirement savings are on track or ahead, compared with 33% of those without one.


That is an association rather than proof that planning caused the difference, and the chart below carries the same note.


Bar chart from Goldman Sachs Asset Management's 2026 Retirement Survey showing 72% of respondents with a personalized plan feel their retirement savings are on track or ahead, compared with 33% of those without one.

I think the direction of it makes sense. A plan does not change how much someone has saved on the day it is written. It replaces a general worry with a specific answer, and it shows what to adjust when the answer is not the one you hoped for. That is why we put as much weight on planning as we do on investing.


One more finding matters for anyone within a decade of retirement. 44% of retirees in the survey said they stopped working earlier than they had planned. Health problems and caring for a family member were among the most common reasons, along with jobs that simply went away.


So we build an early-retirement scenario into every plan. If a client tells us 65 is the target, we also run the plan at 62 and make sure it still holds up. With close to one in two retirees ending up on a different timeline than they expected, it is far better to learn how an earlier date affects you in a planning meeting than in a conversation with HR.


Tech and Rising Rates


The Nasdaq Composite reached a new all-time high on October 6, after a September that was rocky for most of the market. The index is heavily weighted toward the largest technology companies, and its path over the last three years has not been smooth.


The chart below marks a 25% decline in early 2025 and an 11% decline earlier this year. Both times, tech recovered and went on to new highs.


Line chart of the Nasdaq Composite from late 2023 through October 6, 2026, marking a 25% decline in early 2025 and an 11% decline in early 2026 before reaching a record 27,716.55.

We have been overweight technology in client portfolios for years. The earnings growth many of these companies produce is very hard to find anywhere else in the market.


The record is more unusual because it came while interest rates kept rising. The 10-year Treasury yield reached 5.31% on October 6, its highest level in about 20 years, and higher rates have usually been a headwind for technology stocks.


When the 10-year first touched 5% in September, our last update compared it with October 2023: "Rates touched 5% for a few days then and fell substantially over the following two months. We would like to see that repeat." It has not repeated so far. The yield kept climbing after breaking above the 4.68% level that capped it for most of the last four years, as the chart below shows.


Line chart of the 10-year Treasury yield from 2022 through October 6, 2026, showing the October 2023 peak near 5%, a multi-year ceiling near 4.68%, and a break above it to 5.31%.

Housing feels it most directly. The average 30-year mortgage rate hit 7.6% on the day we filmed, and the housing market remains largely frozen. We would like to see rates come down for that reason alone.


Over the last month, technology has led anyway. QQQ, the fund that tracks the Nasdaq 100, gained 5.89% against 1.27% for the S&P 500. The equal-weighted S&P 500, a better read on the average stock, lost 2.92%. Small caps did worse, with the Russell 2000 down 4.21%.


The one-month comparison below also includes the Dow, international stocks and gold.


One-month price change for major ETFs through October 5, 2026: QQQ up 5.89%, SPY up 1.27%, emerging markets flat, and the equal-weight S&P 500, Dow, developed international, Russell 2000 and gold all lower.

The part of the market usually seen as most exposed to higher rates has done the best. We did not expect that combination, and we are glad our tech holdings have been on the right side of it.


Tech's Long-Term Volatility


The biggest long-term winners in technology have also delivered some of the deepest declines. Over the ten years through August 31, 2026, the S&P 500 returned 315% with a worst drawdown of 34%, while several large technology stocks gained far more and fell much further along the way.


The chart below sets each stock's 10-year total return beside its largest peak-to-trough decline.



Meta's 358% return included a 77% decline. Netflix fell 76% on its way to a 732% gain. Nvidia's 14,550% gain came with a 66% drawdown in the middle of it.


Selling during one of those declines would have felt prudent at the time, and for these companies over the last decade it was the wrong decision. The gains went to investors who held through the volatility, which is why we stay with names whose long-term case has not changed when the price drops.


Fed Expectations


At the start of 2026, fed funds futures priced in roughly two rate cuts this year, with the policy rate ending 2026 near 3.05%. As of September 29, the same market expects the year to end at 4.28%, which implies more hikes rather than cuts.


The chart below compares those two paths month by month.



We said last month that we thought the Fed's September hike was a mistake, and it went ahead anyway. The 10-year followed a similar script. It started the year at 4.14%, and plenty of forecasters expected it to drift into the 3s.


Had anyone told us in January that October would bring rising rate expectations and a 10-year above 5%, we would have expected a much weaker stock market. The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq are at record highs instead, and that resilience has been one of the best developments of the year.


The Labor Market


The September jobs report showed just 29,000 jobs added, and the prior two months were revised down by more than 60,000 combined. After revisions, August came in at a solid 133,000 and July showed a loss of 10,000.


The chart below shows how uneven the monthly numbers have been over the last year.



We would like to see consistent monthly gains in the 50,000 to 100,000-plus range, and that has not started yet. A single report is also only one indicator, and the weekly data looks much healthier.


Initial claims for unemployment insurance came in at 197,000 last week. That is a very low number, and it has stayed low for three to four months. Anyone worried about a recession was watching for a move above 300,000, and it is not happening. Layoffs are rare, and most people who lose a job are finding another one quickly.


Claims have stayed near the bottom of their range for most of 2026, as the chart below shows.


Line chart of weekly US initial jobless claims from 2022 through early October 2026, holding mostly between 190,000 and 260,000 and falling to 197,000 in the latest week.

Continuing claims tell a similar story. The number of people still collecting benefits rose from early 2024 through the end of 2025 to nearly 2 million, which was starting to look like a concern. It has fallen steadily this year, with the sharpest drop in the last two to three months.


The chart below tracks that climb and the reversal.


Line chart of US continuing jobless claims from late 2023 through early October 2026, rising to nearly 1.96 million in 2025 before declining through 2026 to 1.701 million.

Average hourly earnings grew 3.0% over the past year, down from 3.1% in our last update and from a 6% peak in 2022. Wages rose quickly from 2021 through 2023 because employers could not find enough workers, and that shortage has eased. The longer view is below.


Line chart of US average hourly earnings growth year over year from 2017 through September 2026, peaking near 6% in 2022 and declining steadily to 3%.

This was one of the reasons we argued the Fed did not need to hike. Wage growth at this level does not create the inflation pressure the economy faced three or four years ago.


Rapid Fire


Fourth-quarter seasonality. The S&P 500 has risen in the fourth quarter in 12 of the last 13 years, with an average gain of 5.4%. The lone decline came in 2018. August through early October tends to be the rougher stretch of the year, and the market enters its historically strongest season with the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq at record highs. The chart below lists each year's result.



Midterm election years. Going back to 1930, the fourth quarter has been roughly twice as strong in midterm years, with an average gain of 5.6% against 2.9% for all years. Many investors assume an election year holds the market back, and in the fourth quarter of a midterm year the history points the other way. The chart below plots the average fourth-quarter path for each part of the election cycle.



Earnings season. Third-quarter reports pick up in mid-October, and expectations are already high at 27% year-over-year earnings growth for the S&P 500. Results usually beat estimates by 2 to 3 percentage points, and they have beaten by far more in each of the last two quarters. If that continues, third-quarter growth could land between 30% and 35%, which would make three straight quarters at that pace. The chart below compares expected and actual growth for each quarter since 2024.




Have questions about what this means for you?


Digging past the headlines to the data underneath is the kind of analysis we bring to every Sentara Capital client relationship. If you'd like to talk through what these numbers mean for your specific situation, we'd welcome the conversation.


Contact Us at (770) 509-5305 to Begin Your Journey


FAQ: Paycheck to Paycheck on a High Income


What does living paycheck to paycheck mean in the Goldman Sachs survey?

It is self-reported. Respondents described their own situation, and the survey did not measure their savings or debt directly. A high earner who answers yes may still have sizable retirement accounts but little cash outside them to cover an emergency without borrowing.


How much of a raise should I save?

There is no single right percentage, and the answer depends on what the rest of your budget and your plan look like. The practical step is to decide before the raise reaches your paycheck, for example by increasing your 401(k) contribution in the same pay period, so the extra income never shows up as spending money.


How do you plan for having to retire earlier than expected?

We run the plan at the target age and again at an earlier one, often three years sooner. The earlier scenario shows the cost of the missing working years: fewer years of contributions, more years of withdrawals, and often a stretch without employer health coverage before Medicare begins at 65. If the plan only works at the original age, that is worth knowing while there is still time to adjust.


Why do rising interest rates usually hurt tech stocks?

Much of a growth company's value comes from earnings expected years in the future, and investors discount those future earnings using rates like the 10-year Treasury. A higher rate makes distant earnings worth less today. Strong current earnings growth can offset that effect, which is part of why technology has held up this year.


Does a strong fourth quarter in past midterm years mean stocks will rise this year?

No. Historical averages describe what tended to happen, not what will happen, and 2018 was itself a midterm year with a fourth-quarter decline. Seasonality is one input among many and is not a reason to change an allocation on its own.


What is the difference between initial and continuing jobless claims?

Initial claims count new filings each week, so they track the pace of layoffs. Continuing claims count everyone still receiving benefits, so they show how long it takes people to find work again. Flat initial claims alongside rising continuing claims would mean layoffs are steady but hiring has slowed.


Another question? Call (770) 509-5305.


Click for Full Transcript

So, the stock market is hitting new all-time highs. In today's video, we're going to take a look at that. Also, unfortunately, interest rates are hitting new 20-year highs. We're going to look at that as well, but we're going to lead off with a new report from Goldman Sachs that looks at the percentage of people living paycheck to paycheck by income level. And the results are going to shock you. Let's dive into it.

We know a lot of people are living paycheck to paycheck, but the results of this study were the real surprise. You can see people making under $50,000 a year, 61% paycheck to paycheck. Then, as your income goes up, $50,000 to $100,000, that drops to 34%. It drops again, down to 22%, for the next income level. But once we get to the $200,000 to $300,000 level, it starts going up, to 25%. And then the big surprise: $300,000 to $500,000 has a big jump up to 34%. And among people making over half a million dollars, 37% said they're living paycheck to paycheck.

Think about that again. That's a bigger percentage over half a million than the people at $50,000 to $100,000. That is a shocker. But we can tell you one reason why this happens, because we've met people in this range, making $400,000, $500,000, $600,000, who have more credit card debt than they have money in savings. A big part of it is keeping up with the Joneses. When people start making more money, they think, "Hey, I can spend more now." And if you see people around you buying bigger houses, buying new cars, sending kids to private schools, you start to do the same kinds of things.

Why this is important is that if you can be aware of it earlier in your career and watch it closely every time you get a raise, don't go spend all of that money. Save first, because otherwise you can end up in this kind of position, making a lot more money but still living paycheck to paycheck.

Another interesting finding from this study asked people how confident they are that their retirement savings is on track, that they're saving enough and will be able to retire. 33% of people who had no planning said they feel like they're on track. So again, two out of three say no, I don't know, I don't feel very confident that I'm on track. But among people who have had a personalized plan done, 72% said they're confident that they are on track. And that's why here at Sentara, we focus on investing, but we also focus on the planning piece, because we have seen that a personalized plan can give people the confidence they need that they're on track, and a game plan to help them meet their financial goals.

One more thing on the planning side. In this survey, they talked to retirees, and 44% said they had to retire earlier than they had planned. The top reasons given were health issues, caring for a family member, or the job no longer being available. So what we do here is, if someone tells us, "Hey, 65 is when I plan to retire," we run scenarios of what happens if you have to retire at 62. We want to make sure you'd be okay, because as we see here, almost one out of every two people are having to retire earlier than they had planned.

In our last video, we talked about how the August, September, October period can be pretty rocky for the financial markets. A lot of September was rocky, but early October has been very good. In fact, parts of the market just hit a new all-time high as we're filming this on October 6, including the Nasdaq, which is tech heavy. Think tech stocks; the big tech names are large percentages of the Nasdaq. Here is a chart of it going back over the last three years, and there have been some pretty significant sell-offs along the way, including one earlier this year. Yet tech has always rallied back. We have been overweight tech for client portfolios for years, because the growth that a lot of these names have is very hard to find anywhere else.

Now, what makes it pretty remarkable that tech just hit an all-time high is that typically when interest rates are going up, tech struggles, and interest rates have continued going up. When we did our last video, the rate on a 10-year Treasury had just hit 5%, and we said we don't want to see this rate stay above 5% for very long. Well, it has kept going. In fact, it's at 5.3%. That is a 20-year high. By the way, this is not good news for housing. We keep talking about this, but the 30-year mortgage today hit 7.6%. Housing is in a freeze. We want to see this going lower to help out housing.

But it is pretty amazing that even though rates have gone up, tech's done very well. In fact, if you look over the last month, during a period where rates have gone up consistently, the Nasdaq, QQQ, is up almost 6%. Compare that to the S&P, which is up just 1.2%. The equal-weighted S&P 500, what's the average stock doing? Down 3%. The Dow Jones Industrial Average is down 3.5%, small caps down 4%. The part of the market that you generally think of as most at risk from higher rates has done the best. It's pretty wild, but we're very glad to see it with the tech holdings that we have.

From time to time, I like to go over the longer-term returns on a lot of these tech stocks versus the biggest sell-offs they've had along the way, because a lot of these stocks have been very volatile. Over the last 10 years, and this is through the end of August 2026, the S&P 500 is up 315%, but it had a decline of over 34% along the way that you had to endure, and a lot of other sell-offs above 20%, I might add. But then take a look at Meta, Amazon and Netflix, up 358%, 576% and 732%. But over on the far left in red, you had to endure sell-offs of 77% for Meta, 56% for Amazon and 76% for Netflix. These are big sell-offs. And drop down to the bottom two. Tesla is up 2,500%, but you had to endure a 74% sell-off. And Nvidia is up over 14,000% with a 66% sell-off.

Again, the point is that from time to time we're going to have a name that has a big sell-off, but the reason we hold on is that these kinds of gains are possible if you're willing to endure some of the volatility. There are some people who panic when they see that kind of blood in the streets, if you will, and sell. That has not been the right decision when it comes to tech over these last 10 years.

Another chart that is simply amazing looks at what the market was expecting the Federal Reserve to do at the start of the year. In our last video, we talked about the fact that the Fed was just about to hike interest rates. We thought it was a mistake, but they went ahead and did it. I don't know why they didn't listen to us, but anyway. Notice that at the start of the year, this number was going down, and the markets thought the Fed rate would be about 3% at the end of 2026, basically saying there were going to be two rate cuts. Instead, this number has gone up, and right now the market is expecting two rate hikes. That is a big gap. If you had told somebody at the start of the year that this is what it would look like in October, we would have thought the stock market would be down a lot. Instead, it's at an all-time high.

The same thing applies, by the way, to the 10-year Treasury we were talking about a little earlier. The rate was 4.14% at the start of the year, and a lot of people thought it was going to go down into the 3s. If you had said, "This will be at 5.3% in early October, where will the stock market be?" we would have thought it would be down a lot. So again, it's very good that the stock market has been so resilient this year in spite of these challenges.

Let's shift gears now and talk about the jobs market. We just got the September jobs report, showing just 29,000 jobs added. Not only that, there was a negative revision to the previous two months, over 60,000 jobs fewer than what had been announced. You can see there 133,000 jobs the previous month. That's a pretty good number, by the way. But in July, a loss of 10,000 jobs. So we're back to a place where the numbers are bumpy month to month. We want to see this go up and get to the 50,000 to 100,000-plus range on a consistent basis, but so far that has not started happening. We'll be watching this number every month and hoping for improvement there.

Now, with the jobs report, you can't just look at one report. You've got to look across a number of different indicators. An example of that is initial claims for unemployment insurance. This is if you're laid off and you can't immediately find another job, so you go file for unemployment insurance. We get this number weekly, and last week it was 197,000. This is a very low number, and it's been very low over the last three or four months. There were people worried that if we were going into a recession, this could go north of 300,000 or 400,000. That is just not happening, meaning there are not many layoffs happening, and when there are, most people are finding another job very quickly.

The companion report to initial claims, also weekly, is continuing claims. This is for people who filed for insurance recently: are they still on it? This number had been going up pretty consistently from early 2024 to the end of 2025 and was starting to be a bit of a concern, with almost 2 million people on continuing claims. But look at what has happened this year. It has been steadily going down and has dropped a lot in the last two or three months. This is very good news. It tells you there's no sign here that the labor market is really starting to struggle.

The last number we want to talk about goes back to the September jobs report, and it's average hourly earnings, meaning wage growth. This number came in at 3%, and it has been on a steady decline ever since early 2022. For a lot of the period from 2021 through 2023, wages were going up a lot because there was a shortage of workers. Companies could not find enough. That is not really the case now, and so this has dropped to 3%. In our last video, by the way, we pointed to this as one of the reasons we didn't think the Fed should be hiking rates, because we don't have the pressures on inflation that we had three or four years ago.

Now it is time for rapid fire, where we go over a couple of key charts we think you need to know about. We're going to start with a chart that shows how the stock market did in the fourth quarter, which again is October 1 through December 31, over the last 13 years. We know August, September and early October can be more challenging, and later in the year is a lot stronger. Over the last 13 years, the stock market has been higher in the fourth quarter 12 times, with only 2018 being the odd man out, so to speak. On average, a 5.4% gain. That is a very strong number. So again, we're entering basically the best time of the year historically for the market, and we're doing it with the S&P and the Nasdaq at all-time highs. We could have a lot more strength ahead.

The next chart also looks at the fourth quarter, going back to 1930, so a much longer time period than the last 13 years. It breaks down fourth-quarter performance in midterm election years versus all others, because one would think that during midterm election years the stock market may not do as well. That is not the case. You can see in black there, all years going back to 1930, 2.9%. We'll round that to 3. But midterm years, up in red, 5.6%. So basically twice as good as all other years. That goes against conventional thinking, and it's another reason to feel optimistic about what's to come in the next couple of months.

That brings us to our last chart, and we have to talk earnings for just a second, because earnings growth this year has been outstanding. We've talked about it all year long in these videos, and the main thing is that earnings have come in much higher than analysts expected every quarter. Why I'm talking about this now is that mid-October is when third-quarter earnings season really starts to heat up, so we'll talk about it in our videos. This chart goes back to the first quarter of 2024. In black is where growth ended up, and the boxes are where analysts thought it was going to end up. The main takeaway is that results normally come in 2% to 3% ahead of what was expected, and in the last two quarters it's been much higher than that. Going into the third quarter, expectations are for 27% growth. So we could very well be looking at a 30% to 35% growth number for the third quarter year over year for the S&P, which would be mind-blowing. That would make it three quarters in a row.

Okay, so the key takeaways. You would think that as you start making more money, things are going to get a lot easier financially. But as that Goldman Sachs report showed, 37% of people making half a million or more said they're living paycheck to paycheck. Planning is so important. Also in that study, 72% of people who had a personalized plan said they're confident they're on track for retirement, versus just 33% of those who didn't. So listen, it is so critical to get a plan. If you don't get it with us, please get it somewhere. We'd love for it to be us. Speaking of that, go to our website, sentaracapital.com. We have a lot of new, updated pages. Go to the contact page and reach out. We'd love to talk to you. Thanks for watching. Take care.


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page